What is the Difference Between Medical Hypnosis and Meditation?

Child laying in a field of grass with eyes closed practicing hypnosis

Both hypnosis and meditation involve changing of the mindset from usual conscious awarenessWhen we are in our usual state of awareness our conscious mind can be highly active, occupied fully with our tasks at hand, and is unaware of input from the subconscious 

How Meditation and Hypnosis are Achieved 

Meditation involves a singular focus such as the breath (mindfulness breathing meditation) or a mantra (transcendental meditation)Such a mental activity allows part of our conscious mind to rest while we are awakeAs we rest, we can become more aware of the moment, including thoughts and feelings from our subconscious. 

In contrast, hypnosis usually involves imagery and suggestions made by a clinician or even self-suggestionsWhen the mind is engaged in imagery, which sometimes is complex and employs all the sensesit is more receptive to suggestionsThis increased receptivity occurs because the mind in hypnosis does not critically evaluate an incoming suggestion, which allows it to better take effectFor example, take the suggestion, “Allow your hand to become numb.”  A mind in its usual state of awareness would reject that suggestion because it would seem impossible to followA mind occupied with imagery in hypnosis, would internalize the suggestion without evaluating its plausibilityIn that circumstance, numbness likely would develop, as many individuals are capable of such a phenomenon 

Purpose of Meditation and Hypnosis   

The purpose of meditation is to allow the mind to clear, to stay in the present moment, and to remain non-judgmental about what is perceived with the five senses or thoughts that may come to mindAnother common mindfulness meditation involves loving kindness in which the focus is on directing loving thoughts towards a specific target (e.g., individuals, groups of people, or the world)Through practice of meditation for 30-40 minutes daily for several weeks, individuals can become calmer and happierfeel more self-aware, have an increased attention span, have improved memory, and express more kindnessResearch has shown that use of meditation for eight weeks can change the physical structure of the brain:  The part of the brain responsible for learning (hippocampus) enlarges, while the part of the brain that is reactive to stressful situations (amygdala) shrinks! 

In contrast, the purpose of hypnosis is to prompt change involving specific goals: Use of hypnosis can achieve most of the benefits reported with meditation and can be applied to improvement in physical or psychological symptoms, athletic performance, insight, or resolution of habitsEffective hypnosis can require only 3-15 minutes of application dailyResearch has shown that hypnosis can change our thought pattern on a subconscious levelHowever, changes in brain structure as has been seen with meditation have not been demonstrated with hypnosis 

Combining Hypnosis and Meditation 

A recent study described combining hypnosis and meditation through introduction of suggestions to engage in mindfulness (e.g., focusing on the breath) while patients were doing hypnosisIt remains to be seen whether such an approach can accelerate the achievement of the physiological benefits that occur with meditation aloneA study that has not been done, to my knowledge, is to examine the effectiveness of providing suggestions to an individual in a meditative stateI suspect that enhanced receptivity to suggestions would occur in such a situationWe would need to evaluate whether such an approach would lead to different outcomes than use of hypnosis alone. 

Children tend to have shorter attention span than adults, and therefore tend to be much more willing to use brief hypnosis interventions than to meditate for much longer periods of time 

Take Home Message 

Hypnosis and meditation both have significant beneficial effectsIf you are seeking to achieve a specific goal, use of hypnosis likely will require less of a time commitment and may be more effective than meditationOn the other hand, meditation has been shown to have physiological benefits that have not been demonstrated with hypnosisThus, meditation may be better for general well-being. 

About Center Point Medicine 

You can learn more about Center Point Medicine, hypnosis, and other great topics by joining our mailing list HERE, following us on social media or heading over to our website. 

For medical professionals looking to open their own Center Point Medicine office providing pediatric counseling and hypnosis services to your local community, please follow this link to learn more about our franchising opportunities. 

 

CPM | Facebook                CPM | LinkedIn                CPM Official Website               CPM Franchise 

Author
Profile Photo or Ran D. Anbar, MD, FAAP Ran D. Anbar, MD Ran D. Anbar, MD, FAAP, is board certified in both pediatric pulmonology and general pediatrics, offering hypnosis and counseling services at Center Point Medicine in La Jolla, California, and Syracuse, New York. Dr. Anbar is also a fellow and approved consultant of the American Society of Clinical Hypnosis. Dr. Anbar is a leader in clinical hypnosis, and his 20 years of experience have allowed him to successfully treat over 5,000 children. He also served as a professor of pediatrics and medicine and the director of pediatric pulmonology at SUNY Upstate Medical University in Syracuse, New York, for 21 years.

You Might Also Enjoy...

How Do You Treat Eczema with Hypnosis?

A patient’s psychology often is involved in the triggering or perpetuation of skin ailments. Hypnosis can be very helpful as a non-medical alternative that can promote healing of the skin.